Return to David's theory of evolution (Evolution)

by David Turell , Saturday, October 08, 2022, 17:26 (775 days ago) @ dhw

DAVID: I have explained dead ends as no longer necessary ecosystems. I have explained God produces only what he feels is necessary. I view humans as a necessary goal. So I feel I do understand God. I can't answer for your confusion.

dhw: 1) Dead-end ecosystems were only “necessary” for the organisms which lived within them and depended on them!

Yes. In all earlier stages up until now.

dhw: 2) If God’s only purpose (as you claim) was to produce sapiens plus food,

This is how you distort the discussion thru the trick of transforming God into a tunnel-visioned fool, who has nothing else on His Mind. This God created a universe, invented life, designed evolution. He knows exactly what He is doing and how to do it.

dhw: 3) What are humans “necessary” for?

Not just as the endpoint of evolution. In this civilized time with a large human population, we now control the Earth And must take care of it. God has done His job

dhw: If your God’s one and only purpose was to design us plus food, how can it have been logical for him to design countless life forms and ecosystems that did not lead to us plus food? Left-behind dead ends did not lead to us plus food! By definition, dead ends lead nowhere. You are still playing silly word games.

Your word games: "This is how you distort the discussion thru the trick of transforming God into a tunnel-visioned fool, who has nothing else on His Mind. This God created a universe, invented life, designed evolution. He knows exactly what He is doing and how to do it." I plan to repeat this until your abandon your silly illogical question.

Microbiome importance

QUOTE: Microbial life was the first to inhabit our planet and will probably be the last.

DAVID: The definition of evolution notes the passage of organisms as new ones appear. Your argument is a distortion of the process.

dhw: We all know that there are countless organisms which are now extinct (= the “passage of organisms”)! And we all know that new ones appeared! The distortion is your absurd claim that all the extinct ones, the majority of which did NOT lead to sapiens and our food, were necessary to fulfil your God’s one and only purpose, which was to design sapiens and our food.

Your word games: "This is how you distort the discussion thru the trick of transforming God into a tunnel-visioned fool, who has nothing else on His Mind. This God created a universe, invented life, designed evolution. He knows exactly what He is doing and how to do it." I plan to repeat this until your abandon your silly illogical question.