Return to David's theory of evolution PARTS 1 & 2 (Evolution)

by David Turell , Wednesday, January 19, 2022, 15:33 (1037 days ago) @ dhw

SURVIVAL

DAVID: Survival is required for ecosystems to work and feed all, nothing more.

dhw: Well yes, if organisms don’t survive, the ecosystem won’t survive, but on the other hand if the food isn’t there, the organisms won’t survive! The organisms eat and are eaten, and that is why ecosystems must be balanced for all the organisms to survive. Now please tell us why large groups of scientists believe that adaptations and innovations do not serve the purpose of improving organisms’ chances of survival.

Same confusion. Survival does not drive speciation is the issue. What group of scientists say what?

Pathogens fight hosts

DAVID:Yes, the humans are in one branch, which goes back to bacteria as all branches do.

dhw: You’ve got it. And yet you still believe, illogically, that even though most of the other extinct branches had no connection with humans and their food, they were part of your God’s goal to produce humans and their food.

That is simply a description of the world of life as it exists today. Everyone eats everyone to have energy to live.

DAVID: I remember the illogic of humans without food.

dhw: Can you or can’t you explain why God evolves [= specially designs] ALL his creations, even though the ONLY creations he wants to evolve are us and our food?

DAVID: That I cannot know God's reasons for using evolution is explanation enough. The others are our food. Back to illogical humans without food.

dhw: Most of the “others” were not OUR food. How many more times? You wrote: that “the current bush of food is NOW for humans NOW. There were smaller bushes in the PAST for PAST forms”, and “Extinct life has no role in current time”. Please stick to your confession that you can’t explain your theory and leave it at that. There is no point in repeatedly trying to dodge the issue with the same old contradictions.

They are illogical only in your strange way of analyzing life's living processes today. All ecosystems involve those at the bottom being eating by those above. Humans are at the very top of the system, and with our numbers, the only way we could be here and expanding our numbers

DAVID: My cohort of IDer's are with me. I have an army of folks.

dhw: Then do please tell me why they all think your God evolved (= individually designed) ALL the life forms etc which had no connection with humans and their food, although his only purpose was to evolve humans and their food[/b].

DAVID: Your illogical complaint never enters their minds. They think just like Adler.

dhw: You mean your illogical theory never enters their minds, just as you say it never entered Adler’s.

They follow the same theory as I do and Adler assumes. God designed all life as He wished to do