Natures wonders: ants and other insects farm (Introduction)

by dhw, Saturday, May 02, 2020, 11:12 (1664 days ago) @ David Turell

DAVID: As I've written elsewhere today, the design you accept which keeps you agnostic, logically requires a very powerful mind.

dhw: Of course if God exists, he has a powerful mind. How does that make dabbling less concrete than inventing autonomous intelligence?

DAVID: Same response. Obviously I don't really know how God controls or manufactures evolution.

None of us knows. So the theoretical invention of autonomous intelligence is no more concrete than the theoretical invention of hands-on dabbling.

xxxxxxxxxxxx

dhw: There are only two ways you can study any living being: 1) the material workings, and 2) the behavioural. How do you know that human memory, storage of information, communication, ability to change behaviour are not “nothing more” than chemical?

DAVID: At the basis they are chemical also, but the use of charged ions is directed into complex networks of axons and changeable dendrites to create human n=mental capacities. The bacterial memory is extremely simple arrangement of ions.

dhw: So bacterial intelligence is not as advanced as human intelligence. I think most of us can accept that.

DAVID: Good.

dhw: Thank you for agreeing that bacterial intelligence is not as advanced as human intelligence. This can only mean that you have agreed that bacteria are intelligent. Progress at last!

DAVID: Your view of 'intelligence' is never mine. I'm just trying to be agreeable.

What attributes would you regard as proof of intelligence?

xxxxxxxxxx

DAVID: Animals and plants must have protective sensors to recognize problems.

dhw: As do we. The cognitive part is how they use these sensors to solve the problems – as do we. More progress: animals and plants have their own forms of cognition, memory, communication, information-processing, decision-making etc. – all elements of what we call intelligence.

DAVID: And I view these sensors as automatic protections, as usual.

So do I. Our own sensors are also automatic. As above, “the cognitive part is how they use these sensors to solve the problems – as do we.”