Natures wonders: Plant awareness (Introduction)

by dhw, Thursday, January 19, 2017, 13:38 (2863 days ago) @ David Turell

QUOTE: "And while many consider terms like "plant intelligence" and "plant neurobiology" to be metaphorical, they have still been met with a lot of criticism, not least from Chamovitz. "Do I think plants are smart? I think plants are complex," he says. Complexity, he says, should not be confused with intelligence. (David's bold)

DAVID’s comment: Plants need these senses. With danger they cannot run and hide. Their reactions are automatic, not intelligent, as stated in the bolded statement above. Since they split off from the original animals, it is not surprising they use the same original proteins. All evolution is based on the same starting proteins.

dhw: As usual, it comes down to definitions. Nobody is arguing that plants philosophize. But if they are sentient and communicate and take decisions, instead of saying plants are not intelligent, one could say plants display a rudimentary form of intelligence.

DAVID: Once again they present intelligently proved responses. Our difference remains.

Not sure what “intelligently proved” means. If a response is intelligent, why argue that it is not intelligent?


Complete thread:

 RSS Feed of thread

powered by my little forum