Errata to Attempt 1 (Agnosticism)

by David Turell , Tuesday, December 20, 2022, 02:36 (703 days ago) @ xeno6696

Matt: A major correction. From the introduction of the Majjhima Nikaya:

"According to the Buddha's teaching, all beings except Arahants are subject to "renewal of being in the future" that is, to rebirth. Rebirth in the Buddhist conception, is not the transmigration of a self or soul but the continuation of a process, a flux of becoming in which successive lives are linked together by causal transmission of influence rather than by substantial identity."

I'll return to this later tonight or tomorrow.

That implies there is no mental continuity, and one would not be conscious of the past life.

Post reply

2036 views

Complete thread:

RSS Feed of thread

In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-10, 18:04
- In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-10, 19:03
  - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-10, 21:17
    - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-10, 22:02
      - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-11, 02:26
- In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - dhw, 2022-12-11, 14:44
  - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-11, 17:55
  - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - dhw, 2022-12-11, 20:47
    - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-11, 22:33
      - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 00:07
    - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-12, 04:41
      - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - dhw, 2022-12-12, 14:08
        In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-12, 16:58
        
        In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-12, 23:56
        
        In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 00:03
      - In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - David Turell, 2022-12-12, 16:51
        In the interest of (maybe) a new discussion... - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 00:09
- The Conversation Continues... - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 04:57
  - The Conversation Continues... - dhw, 2022-12-13, 09:13
    - The Conversation Continues... - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 16:01
    - My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 16:18
      - My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 16:54
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 18:46
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 02:26
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-14, 03:42
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 05:01
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-15, 03:39
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-15, 09:06
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-15, 16:13
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-15, 16:11
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-14, 13:45
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 14:53
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-15, 14:59
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-15, 16:27
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-16, 08:24
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-16, 15:57
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-16, 16:26
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-16, 20:03
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-17, 10:08
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-17, 17:00
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-17, 20:23
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-18, 00:07
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-18, 13:48
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-18, 16:12
        
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-17, 05:27
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-17, 15:50
    - My Experience with Buddhism Pt. 2 - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 16:19
      - My Experience with Buddhism Pt. 3 - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 16:24
        My Experience with Buddhism Pt. 3 - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 17:02
      - My Experience with Buddhism Pt. 2 - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 17:00
    - My Experience with Buddhism Pt 4 - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 21:25
      - My Experience with Buddhism Pt 4 - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 02:36
  - The Conversation Continues... - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 15:46
    - The Conversation Continues... - xeno6696, 2022-12-13, 18:55
      - The Conversation Continues... - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 02:31
        The Conversation Continues... - xeno6696, 2022-12-14, 04:01
        The Conversation Continues... - David Turell, 2022-12-14, 05:12
- Rebirth Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-17, 22:16
  - Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-18, 00:13
  - Rebirth Attempt 1 - dhw, 2022-12-18, 14:06
    - Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-18, 16:18
    - Rebirth Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-19, 20:09
      - Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-19, 22:43
      - Errata to Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-19, 23:57
        Errata to Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-20, 02:36
    - Rebirth Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-19, 20:10
      - Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-19, 22:52
        Rebirth Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-19, 23:54
        Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-20, 02:33
        Rebirth Attempt 1 - xeno6696, 2022-12-20, 15:40
        Rebirth Attempt 1 - David Turell, 2022-12-21, 00:22
      - Rebirth PART ONE - dhw, 2022-12-20, 09:04
        Rebirth PART TWO - dhw, 2022-12-20, 09:10
        Rebirth PART TWO - David Turell, 2022-12-20, 16:17
        
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-20, 16:14
        
        Rebirth PART ONE - xeno6696, 2022-12-22, 03:59
        Rebirth PART ONE - dhw, 2022-12-22, 09:35
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-22, 19:26
        
        Rebirth PART ONE - xeno6696, 2022-12-22, 23:26
        Rebirth PART ONE - dhw, 2022-12-23, 12:47
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-23, 16:51
        
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-23, 15:58
        
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-22, 18:57
        Rebirth PART ONE - xeno6696, 2022-12-22, 23:31
        Rebirth PART ONE - David Turell, 2022-12-23, 16:01
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-10, 18:19
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - xeno6696, 2024-05-10, 20:42
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-10, 22:12
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - xeno6696, 2024-05-11, 05:40
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - dhw, 2024-05-11, 08:43
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - xeno6696, 2024-05-14, 16:01
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-15, 00:09
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - xeno6696, 2024-05-15, 00:48
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-15, 15:40
        
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - dhw, 2024-05-15, 09:48
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-15, 16:02
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-15, 16:55
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-16, 11:26
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-16, 11:42
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-16, 20:14
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-16, 21:34
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-16, 21:16
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-17, 13:58
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-17, 15:45
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-17, 18:55
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-17, 21:36
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 16:00
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-18, 16:15
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 17:49
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-18, 08:53
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-18, 10:24
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-18, 16:23
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 17:53
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 16:48
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-18, 15:57
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 16:52
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-19, 13:25
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-19, 16:24
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-19, 18:50
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-19, 21:24
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-20, 09:43
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-20, 18:13
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-20, 21:39
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-20, 21:47
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-20, 22:05
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-21, 12:15
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-21, 16:35
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-21, 17:29
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-21, 21:22
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-21, 23:38
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-22, 12:41
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-22, 18:03
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-22, 22:09
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-23, 14:11
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-23, 20:40
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-24, 02:01
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-24, 17:04
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-24, 18:53
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-25, 20:49
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-25, 13:33
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-25, 21:44
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-25, 21:49
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - dhw, 2024-05-26, 08:49
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-26, 17:07
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-26, 17:37
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 22:14
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-28, 23:34
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-26, 17:09
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-26, 17:44
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 22:18
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-27, 11:47
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-27, 11:53
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-27, 17:05
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 22:27
        Mat: Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-28, 23:39
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 22:24
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-27, 16:56
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 23:25
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-28, 23:53
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-29, 13:14
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-29, 13:25
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-29, 18:18
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-29, 23:28
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 00:26
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 00:30
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-30, 06:06
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 19:07
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-29, 18:15
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-29, 22:54
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 00:21
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-30, 13:46
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-30, 13:53
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 20:12
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-31, 00:43
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-30, 20:09
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-30, 23:00
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-05-31, 12:45
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - dhw, 2024-05-31, 12:54
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-31, 16:44
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-06-08, 16:22
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-06-08, 16:44
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - dhw, 2024-06-09, 12:18
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-06-09, 17:16
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 22:51
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-28, 23:43
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-26, 17:15
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-26, 16:41
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-28, 23:02
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-28, 23:46
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-23, 19:52
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-24, 02:08
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-24, 17:12
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-23, 00:24
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-23, 20:00
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-21, 17:17
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-19, 16:25
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-19, 18:57
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-19, 21:43
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-20, 18:07
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-19, 16:31
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 16:42
        
        Nibbana tangent parts 1 & 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-17, 18:48
        
        A brief word on methodology. - xeno6696, 2024-05-18, 02:16
        A brief word on methodology. - David Turell, 2024-05-18, 16:03
        
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - xeno6696, 2024-05-16, 21:16
        Nibbana tangent part 1 - David Turell, 2024-05-17, 18:41
        
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-15, 16:02
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-15, 17:08
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-15, 17:53
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - David Turell, 2024-05-16, 18:13
        Nibbana tangent part 2 - xeno6696, 2024-05-16, 22:07
        
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-15, 16:46
        
        Rebirth PART ONE: evidence in young children - David Turell, 2024-05-11, 18:29

AgnosticWeb.com

Errata to Attempt 1 (Agnosticism)