An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' (Evolution)

by David Turell , Saturday, December 03, 2016, 00:32 (2702 days ago) @ dhw

dhw: In my original post I asked what part of his thesis you were talking about: “Common descent? Natural selection? Or the same old random mutations plus gradualism that you and I have long since agreed to discount?” So you are indeed back to flogging the dead horse of gradualism.

DAVID: What is it you think is missing from my discussion? The only thing that Darwin proposed that is without question for me is common descent with modification. How modification occurred is still up for grabs. Remember, for all we know God could be doing the genetic modification.

dhw:So Darwin’s thesis of common descent in fact IS supported by genetic modification. But how it happened is still up for grabs, though you and I agree that however it happened, it would not have been random or gradual. Shake hands on this one?

No gradualism and we do shake hands on evolution by common descent as Darwin's only real contribution.

Post reply

8063 views

Complete thread:

RSS Feed of thread

An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-08-30, 12:11
- An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-08-30, 12:29
  - An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-08-30, 21:27
    - An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-08-31, 01:02
      - An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-08-31, 04:08
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-08-31, 06:18
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-08-31, 08:12
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-08-31, 16:28
    - An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-01, 13:20
      - An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-01, 18:59
- An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-08-30, 23:36
  - An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-01, 13:01
    - An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-01, 18:39
    - An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-02, 05:02
      - An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-02, 20:50
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-02, 21:04
        
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-02, 21:28
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-03, 02:00
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-03, 22:00
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-04, 04:44
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-05, 12:48
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-05, 19:23
        
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-05, 20:42
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-06, 11:40
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-06, 19:21
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-08, 12:15
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-09, 00:59
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-09, 22:10
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-10, 11:34
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-10, 19:44
        
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-06, 21:29
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-06, 22:40
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-08, 12:21
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-08, 21:13
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-10, 11:21
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-10, 19:32
        
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-10, 21:42
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-11, 16:00
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-11, 20:19
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-11, 21:53
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-12, 08:15
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-12, 20:37
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-13, 00:52
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-13, 16:39
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-13, 21:05
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-13, 21:57
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-14, 03:39
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-14, 05:55
        An inventive mechanism - Balance_Maintained, 2014-09-14, 10:35
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-11, 20:27
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-11, 22:21
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-13, 09:30
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-16, 12:29
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-16, 19:09
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-17, 20:34
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-17, 22:06
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-18, 18:22
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-22, 19:50
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-23, 12:55
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-23, 15:05
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-24, 15:28
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-25, 19:42
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-26, 12:49
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-26, 15:05
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-27, 16:50
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-28, 01:56
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-28, 20:24
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-29, 00:34
        An inventive mechanism: Transposition - David Turell, 2014-09-29, 15:15
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-29, 16:01
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-30, 15:25
        An inventive mechanism: polyploidy? - David Turell, 2014-10-01, 15:05
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-01, 20:01
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-02, 02:32
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-02, 18:23
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-02, 19:23
        An inventive mechanism - GateKeeper, 2014-10-03, 14:30
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-03, 14:41
        
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-04, 01:27
        
        An inventive mechanism: 3-color vision - David Turell, 2014-10-03, 14:45
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-03, 18:18
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-03, 20:00
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-04, 15:48
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-04, 19:47
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - David Turell, 2014-10-05, 15:30
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - dhw, 2014-10-06, 12:25
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - David Turell, 2014-10-06, 23:43
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - dhw, 2014-10-07, 16:09
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - David Turell, 2014-10-07, 18:31
        
        An inventive mechanism; Reviewing Talbott - David Turell, 2014-10-09, 02:19
        
        An inventive mechanism; Read this essay - David Turell, 2014-10-07, 01:46
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-05, 21:33
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-06, 00:01
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-06, 12:16
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-06, 15:57
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-07, 15:53
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-07, 18:05
        An inventive mechanism: Tacoma bridge adddendum - David Turell, 2014-10-08, 01:42
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-08, 13:12
        An inventive mechanism: another outside discussion - David Turell, 2014-10-08, 19:02
        An inventive mechanism: another outside discussion - dhw, 2014-10-09, 20:15
        An inventive mechanism: another outside discussion - David Turell, 2014-10-10, 02:15
        An inventive mechanism: another outside discussion - dhw, 2014-10-10, 15:31
        An inventive mechanism: another outside discussion - David Turell, 2014-10-10, 17:58
        
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-08, 20:21
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-09, 19:39
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-10, 01:36
        An inventive mechanism: bed bugs - David Turell, 2014-10-10, 15:05
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-10, 15:26
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-10, 17:53
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-11, 12:45
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-11, 15:22
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-12, 11:41
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-10-12, 15:02
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-10-13, 16:41
        
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - David Turell, 2014-11-06, 15:27
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - Balance_Maintained, 2014-11-07, 06:42
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - dhw, 2014-11-07, 13:18
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - David Turell, 2014-11-07, 16:36
        
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - David Turell, 2014-11-07, 16:03
        An inventive mechanism; developing multicellularity - David Turell, 2015-02-05, 15:34
        Developing multicellularity; bacterial example - David Turell, 2015-05-25, 15:29
        Developing multicellularity; poor lab example - David Turell, 2015-07-03, 04:57
        Developing multicellularity; from a virus? - David Turell, 2018-02-17, 14:40
        
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-24, 15:37
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-25, 02:16
        
        An inventive mechanism; another adaptation - David Turell, 2014-09-25, 15:11
        An inventive mechanism: nylon eating bacteria - David Turell, 2014-11-10, 22:10
        An inventive mechanism: nylon eating bacteria - dhw, 2014-11-11, 13:34
        An inventive mechanism: nylon eating bacteria - David Turell, 2014-11-11, 14:00
        
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-06, 15:32
        
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-04, 06:11
        An inventive mechanism - dhw, 2014-09-05, 12:37
        
        An inventive mechanism - David Turell, 2014-09-03, 02:18
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-11-28, 15:41
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - dhw, 2014-11-29, 11:57
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-11-29, 15:49
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - dhw, 2014-11-30, 19:52
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-12-01, 00:58
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - dhw, 2014-12-01, 17:28
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-12-02, 17:40
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - dhw, 2014-12-03, 18:00
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-12-03, 22:17
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - dhw, 2014-12-04, 17:49
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2016-11-27, 15:23
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - dhw, 2016-11-29, 09:03
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2016-11-29, 19:37
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - dhw, 2016-11-30, 12:23
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2016-11-30, 15:38
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - dhw, 2016-12-01, 13:13
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2016-12-01, 19:09
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - dhw, 2016-12-02, 10:37
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2016-12-03, 00:32
        An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' - David Turell, 2021-01-22, 23:29
        
        An inventive mechanism: role of horizontal gene transfer - David Turell, 2014-12-01, 15:29

AgnosticWeb.com

An inventive mechanism: A DNA 'Shapiro change' (Evolution)