Evolution: ancient sulfur-eating bacteria (Introduction)
A good explanation how studies of isotopes that have been left by early life show how they lived on energy from sulfur and other mineral sources, and not from eating each other:
https://phys.org/news/2019-02-life-earth-billion-years.html
"Microbial metabolism is recorded in billions of years of sulfur isotope ratios that agree with this study's predictions, suggesting that life flourished in the ancient oceans. Using this data, scientists can more deeply link the geochemical record with cellular states and ecology.
***
" Presently, the oldest evidence of microbial life on Earth comes to us in the form of stable isotopes. The chemical elements charted on the periodic table are defined by the number of protons in their nuclei. For example, hydrogen atoms have one proton, helium atoms have two, carbon atoms contain six. In addition to protons, most atomic nuclei also contain neutrons, which are about as heavy as protons, but which don't bear an electric charge. Atoms that contain the same number of protons, but variable numbers of neutrons, are known as isotopes. While many isotopes are radioactive and thus decay into other elements, some do not undergo such reactions; these are known as "stable" isotopes. For example, the stable isotopes of carbon include carbon 12 (written as 12C for short, with 6 protons and 6 neutrons) and carbon 13 (13C, with 6 protons and 7 neutrons).
"All living things, including humans, "eat and excrete." That is to say, they take in food and expel waste. Microbes often eat simple compounds made available by the environment. For example, some are able to take in carbon dioxide (CO2) as a carbon source to build their own cells. Naturally occurring CO2 has a fairly constant ratio of 12C to 13C. However, 12CO2 is about 2 percent lighter than 13CO2, so 12CO2 molecules diffuse and react slightly faster, and thus the microbes themselves become "isotopically light," containing more 12C than 13C, and when they die and leave their remains in the fossil record, their stable isotopic signature remains, and is measurable. The isotopic composition, or "signature," of such processes can be very specific to the microbes that produce them.
"Besides carbon, there are other chemical elements essential for living things. For example, sulfur, with 16 protons, has three naturally abundant stable isotopes, 32S (with 16 neutrons), 33S (with 17 neutrons) and 34S (with 18 neutrons). Sulfur isotope patterns left behind by microbes thus record the history of biological metabolism based on sulfur-containing compounds back to around 3.5 billion years ago.
"Hundreds of previous studies have examined wide variations in ancient and contemporary sulfur isotope ratios resulting from sulfate (a naturally occurring sulfur compound bonded to four oxygen atoms) metabolism. Many microbes are able to use sulfate as a fuel, and in the process excrete sulfide, another sulfur compound (Figure 1). The sulfide "waste" of ancient microbial metabolism is then stored in the geological record, and its isotope ratios can be measured by analyzing minerals such as the FeS2 mineral pyrite.
"This new study reveals a primary biological control step in microbial sulfur metabolism, and clarifies which cellular states lead to which types of sulfur isotope fractionation. This allows scientists to link metabolism to isotopes: By knowing how metabolism changes stable isotope ratios, scientists can predict the isotopic signature organisms should leave behind.
"This study provides some of the first information regarding how robustly ancient life was metabolizing. Microbial sulfate metabolism is recorded in over 3 billion years of sulfur isotope ratios that are in line with this study's predictions, which suggest life was in fact thriving in the ancient oceans."
Comment: This is very important article as it explains how early bacteria could live on the energy in electrons from minerals. Evolving life has always needed energy intake and excretion of waste products and will leave traces. Bacteria are extremely complex creatures as they must do everything we do but within one cell. Early life couldn't find much protein to ingest fore energy , so this was required, and it is still seen today in extremeophiles.
Complete thread:
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-04-28, 15:15
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-04-29, 13:18
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-04-29, 18:51
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-04-30, 21:06
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-01, 02:49
- Evolution: a different view; convergence -
David Turell,
2015-05-01, 14:32
- Evolution: convergence or parallelism -
David Turell,
2017-08-09, 23:39
- Evolution: convergence or parallelism -
dhw,
2017-08-10, 09:01
- Evolution: convergence or parallelism - David Turell, 2017-08-10, 18:34
- Evolution: convergence or divergence - David Turell, 2021-01-12, 19:15
- Evolution: plant blooms -
David Turell,
2021-09-16, 19:52
- Evolution: plant blooms pushed further back - David Turell, 2022-01-17, 15:12
- Evolution: convergence or parallelism -
dhw,
2017-08-10, 09:01
- Evolution: convergence or parallelism -
David Turell,
2017-08-09, 23:39
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-02, 08:39
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-02, 21:40
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-02, 21:50
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-03, 00:53
- Evolution: a different view; Ian Tattersall -
David Turell,
2015-06-19, 18:04
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-28, 14:39
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
dhw,
2015-08-28, 18:44
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-28, 22:22
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
dhw,
2015-08-29, 08:14
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-29, 14:12
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz - dhw, 2015-08-30, 21:21
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-29, 14:12
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
dhw,
2015-08-29, 08:14
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-28, 22:22
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
dhw,
2015-08-28, 18:44
- Evolution: a different view; Schwartz -
David Turell,
2015-08-28, 14:39
- Evolution: a different view; Ian Tattersall -
David Turell,
2015-06-19, 18:04
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2016-04-21, 01:52
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2016-04-21, 14:11
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2016-04-22, 05:21
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2016-04-22, 15:22
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2016-04-22, 15:47
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2016-04-22, 15:22
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2016-04-22, 05:21
- Evolution: a different view: correction - David Turell, 2016-04-22, 15:19
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2016-09-24, 19:19
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2016-04-21, 14:11
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-03, 00:53
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-04, 18:40
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-05, 00:15
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-06, 21:23
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-06, 22:18
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-07, 09:12
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-07, 15:13
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-07, 15:50
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-08, 01:31
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-09, 12:04
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-09, 21:29
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 09:45
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 15:26
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 17:55
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 18:51
- Evolution: a different view - Balance_Maintained, 2015-05-10, 19:29
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 18:51
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 17:55
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 15:26
- Evolution: a different view: ape speech - David Turell, 2015-08-16, 04:11
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 09:45
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-09, 21:29
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-09, 12:04
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-08, 01:31
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-07, 21:55
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-08, 02:06
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-09, 11:30
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-09, 21:53
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 09:49
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2015-05-10, 15:22
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-10, 21:13
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 21:49
- Evolution: a different method, polyploidy - David Turell, 2015-05-11, 01:16
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-11, 16:53
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-11, 21:49
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-12, 22:42
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-13, 00:33
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-14, 13:46
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-14, 19:05
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-15, 17:47
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-15, 18:03
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-16, 12:55
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-16, 21:49
- Evolution: a different view - Balance_Maintained, 2015-05-17, 08:47
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-16, 21:49
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-16, 12:55
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-15, 18:03
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-15, 22:33
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-16, 00:17
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-17, 12:26
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-17, 19:41
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-18, 22:41
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-19, 01:02
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-20, 19:33
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-20, 20:48
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-22, 08:27
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-22, 21:51
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-23, 12:03
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2015-05-23, 15:00
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-24, 17:35
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2015-05-24, 18:57
- Evolution: a different view of heart design - David Turell, 2020-08-22, 22:53
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-23, 12:03
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-23, 11:30
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-23, 14:36
- Evolution: Micro vs. macroevolution -
David Turell,
2015-06-02, 23:22
- Evolution: Micro vs. macroevolution -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-06-03, 07:40
- Evolution: Computer simulations of mutations -
David Turell,
2015-06-08, 22:18
- Evolution: ancient sulphur-eating bacteria -
David Turell,
2016-11-30, 15:00
- Evolution: earliest plants older than thought -
David Turell,
2017-03-15, 00:49
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-21, 23:19
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-22, 10:47
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-22, 15:06
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-23, 09:27
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-23, 22:43
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-24, 13:20
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-24, 16:07
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-25, 13:20
- Evolution: dinosaurs not as dominant as thought -
David Turell,
2017-08-10, 19:07
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-26, 20:21
- Evolution:mammal perineum appears pre-planned - David Turell, 2017-08-27, 00:30
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
dhw,
2017-08-27, 10:56
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-27, 20:01
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
dhw,
2017-08-28, 13:19
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-28, 19:21
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-21, 20:51
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-25, 14:23
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-26, 12:06
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-26, 17:11
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-27, 10:51
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-27, 15:13
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-28, 12:58
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-28, 14:28
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-28, 20:02
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-29, 13:53
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-29, 18:22
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-30, 12:44
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-30, 18:52
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-31, 14:10
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-31, 16:21
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
David Turell,
2018-09-25, 17:44
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-09-25, 21:10
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
David Turell,
2018-09-25, 22:21
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-07, 20:27
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-08, 06:07
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work - David Turell, 2018-10-08, 14:41
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-08, 14:17
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-08, 14:52
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work - David Turell, 2018-10-08, 14:54
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-09, 09:17
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-09, 17:40
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-10, 09:29
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-10, 17:55
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-11, 11:52
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-11, 15:35
- Evolution: first animals before the Cambrian -
David Turell,
2018-10-15, 18:33
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-24, 15:33
- Evolution: Darwinist wishful thinking -
David Turell,
2018-10-24, 22:35
- Evolution: Darwinist wishful thinking - Balance_Maintained, 2018-10-25, 00:24
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
dhw,
2018-10-25, 11:08
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-25, 15:12
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-25, 18:38
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-26, 11:28
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-26, 15:16
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-27, 09:34
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-27, 19:28
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-29, 05:30
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-29, 12:33
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-29, 16:53
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk - David Turell, 2018-10-29, 21:24
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk - dhw, 2018-10-30, 08:54
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-29, 21:17
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk - David Turell, 2022-07-19, 23:26
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-29, 16:53
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-29, 12:33
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-29, 05:30
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-27, 19:28
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-27, 09:34
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-26, 15:16
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
dhw,
2018-10-26, 11:28
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
dhw,
2018-10-26, 11:07
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-26, 14:58
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
dhw,
2018-10-27, 09:26
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-27, 19:15
- Evolution: marine snow econiche -
David Turell,
2018-12-03, 19:03
- Evolution: plankton and the ocean/carbon cycle - David Turell, 2019-10-02, 20:12
- Evolution: development of flying not understood - David Turell, 2022-08-03, 18:37
- Evolution: marine snow econiche -
David Turell,
2018-12-03, 19:03
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-27, 19:15
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
dhw,
2018-10-27, 09:26
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-26, 14:58
- Evolution: development of the elephant trunk -
David Turell,
2018-10-25, 18:38
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-25, 15:12
- Evolution: Darwinist wishful thinking -
David Turell,
2018-10-24, 22:35
- Evolution: first life fossils on Earth - David Turell, 2022-11-11, 00:06
- Evolution: development of flying not understood -
David Turell,
2018-10-24, 15:33
- Evolution: first animals before the Cambrian -
David Turell,
2018-10-15, 18:33
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-11, 15:35
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-11, 11:52
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-10, 17:55
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
dhw,
2018-10-10, 09:29
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-09, 17:40
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-08, 14:52
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-10-08, 06:07
- Evolution: materialism explanation doesn't work -
David Turell,
2018-10-07, 20:27
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life - David Turell, 2019-06-26, 18:57
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
David Turell,
2018-09-25, 22:21
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
Balance_Maintained,
2018-09-25, 21:10
- Evolution: only genetics can design a bush of life -
David Turell,
2018-09-25, 17:44
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-31, 16:21
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-31, 14:10
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-30, 18:52
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-30, 12:44
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-29, 18:22
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
dhw,
2018-01-29, 13:53
- Evolution: common descent not shown by genetics -
David Turell,
2018-01-28, 20:02
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-28, 14:28
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-28, 12:58
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-27, 15:13
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-27, 10:51
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-26, 17:11
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
dhw,
2017-09-26, 12:06
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-25, 14:23
- Evolution: poisonous frog self-protection -
David Turell,
2017-09-21, 20:51
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-28, 19:21
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
dhw,
2017-08-28, 13:19
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-27, 20:01
- Evolution: hybridization is relatively common -
David Turell,
2017-08-26, 20:21
- Evolution: dinosaurs not as dominant as thought -
David Turell,
2017-08-10, 19:07
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-25, 13:20
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-24, 16:07
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-24, 13:20
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-23, 22:43
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-23, 09:27
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-22, 15:06
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
dhw,
2017-07-22, 10:47
- Evolution: an ability Darwin does not explain -
David Turell,
2017-07-21, 23:19
- Evolution: ancient sulfur-eating bacteria -
David Turell,
2019-02-08, 18:46
- Evolution: ancient sulfur-eating bacteria and carbon 12-13 -
David Turell,
2019-02-10, 00:42
- Evolution: the color of blood -
David Turell,
2019-04-27, 23:30
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
David Turell,
2019-08-15, 22:13
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
dhw,
2019-08-16, 08:45
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
David Turell,
2019-08-16, 16:01
- Evolution: the influence of parasites -
David Turell,
2019-08-24, 19:02
- Evolution: teeth designed to last a lifetime - David Turell, 2019-09-27, 16:07
- Evolution: the influence of parasites -
David Turell,
2019-08-24, 19:02
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
David Turell,
2019-08-16, 16:01
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
dhw,
2019-08-16, 08:45
- Evolution: factors for speed of diversification -
David Turell,
2019-08-15, 22:13
- Evolution: the color of blood -
David Turell,
2019-04-27, 23:30
- Evolution: ancient sulfur-eating bacteria and carbon 12-13 -
David Turell,
2019-02-10, 00:42
- Evolution: earliest plants older than thought -
David Turell,
2017-03-15, 00:49
- Evolution: ancient sulphur-eating bacteria -
David Turell,
2016-11-30, 15:00
- Evolution: Computer simulations of mutations -
David Turell,
2015-06-08, 22:18
- Evolution: Micro vs. macroevolution -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-06-03, 07:40
- Evolution: Micro vs. macroevolution -
David Turell,
2015-06-02, 23:22
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-23, 14:36
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-22, 21:51
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-22, 08:27
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-20, 20:48
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-20, 19:33
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-19, 01:02
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-18, 22:41
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-17, 19:41
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-17, 12:26
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-16, 00:17
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-15, 17:47
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-14, 19:05
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-14, 13:46
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-13, 00:33
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-12, 22:42
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-11, 21:49
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-10, 21:49
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-10, 09:49
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-09, 21:53
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-09, 11:30
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-08, 02:06
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-07, 15:50
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-07, 15:13
- Evolution: a different view -
Balance_Maintained,
2015-05-07, 09:12
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-06, 22:18
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-05-06, 21:23
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-05, 00:15
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-02, 21:50
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-02, 21:40
- Evolution: a different view; convergence -
David Turell,
2015-05-01, 14:32
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-05-01, 02:49
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-04-30, 21:06
- Evolution: a different view -
David Turell,
2015-04-29, 18:51
- Evolution: a different view -
George Jelliss,
2015-05-21, 21:52
- Evolution: a different view - David Turell, 2015-05-22, 02:26
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits -
David Turell,
2018-11-16, 00:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits - David Turell, 2018-11-16, 02:02
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish -
David Turell,
2018-12-03, 19:14
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish -
dhw,
2018-12-04, 14:40
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish -
David Turell,
2018-12-04, 18:44
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2018-12-04, 19:04
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2020-10-01, 17:58
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2020-10-02, 21:31
- Evolution: possible origin of apoptosis -
David Turell,
2020-10-05, 23:38
- Evolution: moles strange heterosexuality -
David Turell,
2020-10-08, 19:53
- Evolution: complexity, protein language & information - David Turell, 2020-10-09, 19:49
- Evolution: a mechanism of apoptosis -
David Turell,
2022-02-17, 19:39
- Evolution: more convergence - David Turell, 2022-02-19, 15:45
- Evolution: moles strange heterosexuality -
David Turell,
2020-10-08, 19:53
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2020-10-10, 19:09
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
dhw,
2020-10-11, 13:02
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth - David Turell, 2020-10-11, 15:35
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
dhw,
2020-10-11, 13:02
- Evolution: possible origin of apoptosis -
David Turell,
2020-10-05, 23:38
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2020-10-02, 21:31
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2020-10-01, 17:58
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish - dhw, 2018-12-05, 11:45
- Evolution: the presence of life evolves the Earth -
David Turell,
2018-12-04, 19:04
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish -
David Turell,
2018-12-04, 18:44
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; jellyfish -
dhw,
2018-12-04, 14:40
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; more Behe -
David Turell,
2019-01-02, 23:33
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; more Behe -
dhw,
2019-01-03, 10:29
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; more Behe -
David Turell,
2019-01-03, 19:04
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-04, 19:17
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-05, 12:52
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-05, 15:13
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-06, 10:44
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-06, 18:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-07, 11:42
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-08, 22:10
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-09, 12:18
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-09, 15:28
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-10, 13:26
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-10, 19:39
- Evolution: a different view with loss of complexity - David Turell, 2019-01-11, 00:42
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-11, 12:59
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments - David Turell, 2019-01-11, 22:45
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-10, 19:39
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-10, 13:26
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-09, 15:28
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-09, 12:18
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-08, 22:10
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-07, 11:42
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-06, 18:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2022-03-27, 17:09
- Evolution: losing legs to make a snake - David Turell, 2022-03-28, 20:38
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-06, 10:44
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-05, 15:13
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
dhw,
2019-01-05, 12:52
- Evolution: a different view with loss of DNA segments -
David Turell,
2019-01-04, 19:17
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; more Behe -
David Turell,
2019-01-03, 19:04
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe - David Turell, 2020-05-20, 15:31
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-01, 17:29
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-02, 11:36
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-02, 20:50
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-03, 11:32
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-03, 19:43
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-04, 09:25
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-04, 18:24
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-05, 11:06
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-05, 19:35
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-06, 12:22
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-06, 15:11
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-07, 14:38
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-07, 15:47
- Evolution: viruses critical role - David Turell, 2020-09-07, 18:50
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-08, 12:13
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-08, 15:58
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-09, 07:36
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-09, 22:47
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-10, 12:51
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-10, 21:13
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-11, 14:12
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-11, 22:18
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-12, 12:51
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-12, 19:14
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-13, 12:56
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-13, 18:49
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-14, 13:57
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-14, 19:00
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-15, 12:01
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-15, 15:23
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-16, 11:01
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-16, 19:23
- Evolution: vertebrate driving genes; not Behe - David Turell, 2020-09-16, 20:40
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-17, 10:34
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-17, 18:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe - dhw, 2020-09-18, 11:09
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-17, 18:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2021-02-18, 01:53
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2021-02-18, 11:19
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2021-02-18, 16:04
- Evolution: Cambrian animal start defined -
David Turell,
2021-11-04, 13:44
- Evolution: strange changes in DNA form - David Turell, 2021-11-06, 14:15
- Evolution: giant aquatic arthropods 470 mya - David Turell, 2022-12-13, 17:25
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2022-01-05, 21:06
- Evolution: mass extinctions relate to volcanos - David Turell, 2022-02-01, 15:25
- Evolution: sudden change from a gene loss - David Turell, 2022-02-16, 19:37
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe - David Turell, 2022-05-02, 19:51
- Evolution: Cambrian animal start defined -
David Turell,
2021-11-04, 13:44
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2021-02-18, 16:04
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2022-08-10, 22:58
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2022-09-23, 19:15
- Evolution: more advances related to more microRNA -
David Turell,
2022-12-16, 21:54
- Evolution: hybridization in ants -
David Turell,
2022-12-21, 21:03
- Evolution: can natural forces drive evolution -
David Turell,
2023-10-04, 19:44
- Evolution: strange animals don't have to eat: -
David Turell,
2023-10-05, 19:54
- Evolution: the angiosperm gap -
David Turell,
2023-10-05, 20:34
- Evolution: the angiosperm gap -
David Turell,
2023-10-27, 19:30
- Evolution: how the complex cell formed -
David Turell,
2023-10-29, 17:02
- Evolution: how bacteria use essential amino acids -
David Turell,
2023-11-23, 17:30
- Evolution: bacteria pass information through generations -
David Turell,
2023-11-23, 18:09
- Evolution: is it predictable? -
David Turell,
2024-01-30, 18:44
- Evolution: new stromatolites in Saudi Arabia -
David Turell,
2024-06-01, 18:03
- Evolution: Lamarck is back -
David Turell,
2024-06-04, 22:14
- Evolution: Darwin's abominable mystery again -
David Turell,
2024-06-14, 16:53
- Evolution: the role of viral DNA -
David Turell,
2024-07-19, 20:06
- Evolution: the origin of a nervous system - David Turell, 2024-08-13, 21:18
- Evolution: the role of viral DNA -
David Turell,
2024-07-19, 20:06
- Evolution: Darwin's abominable mystery again -
David Turell,
2024-06-14, 16:53
- Evolution: Lamarck is back -
David Turell,
2024-06-04, 22:14
- Evolution: new stromatolites in Saudi Arabia -
David Turell,
2024-06-01, 18:03
- Evolution: is it predictable? -
David Turell,
2024-01-30, 18:44
- Evolution: bacteria pass information through generations -
David Turell,
2023-11-23, 18:09
- Evolution: how bacteria use essential amino acids -
David Turell,
2023-11-23, 17:30
- Evolution: how the complex cell formed -
David Turell,
2023-10-29, 17:02
- Evolution: the angiosperm gap -
David Turell,
2023-10-27, 19:30
- Evolution: the angiosperm gap -
David Turell,
2023-10-05, 20:34
- Evolution: strange animals don't have to eat: -
David Turell,
2023-10-05, 19:54
- Evolution: can natural forces drive evolution -
David Turell,
2023-10-04, 19:44
- Evolution: hybridization in ants -
David Turell,
2022-12-21, 21:03
- Evolution: more advances related to more microRNA -
David Turell,
2022-12-16, 21:54
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2022-09-23, 19:15
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2021-02-18, 11:19
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-16, 19:23
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-16, 11:01
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-15, 15:23
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-15, 12:01
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-14, 19:00
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-14, 13:57
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-13, 18:49
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-13, 12:56
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-12, 19:14
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-12, 12:51
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-11, 22:18
- Evolution: how viruses might fit in - David Turell, 2021-04-25, 17:17
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-11, 14:12
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-10, 21:13
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-10, 12:51
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-09, 22:47
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-09, 07:36
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-08, 15:58
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-07, 15:47
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-07, 14:38
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-06, 15:11
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-06, 12:22
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-05, 19:35
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-05, 11:06
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-04, 18:24
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-04, 09:25
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-03, 19:43
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-03, 11:32
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
David Turell,
2020-09-02, 20:50
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; not Behe -
dhw,
2020-09-02, 11:36
- Evolution: a different view with loss of traits; more Behe -
dhw,
2019-01-03, 10:29
- Evolution: a different view -
dhw,
2015-04-29, 13:18