How children may pick up a language (Humans)
by David Turell 
, Monday, May 09, 2016, 15:28 (3119 days ago) @ dhw
> dhw: However, a child can only learn from what it hears. A feral child will have no grasp of human language, but if brought up by wild animals will “speak” their language. There are known cases in which such children later had great difficulty coping with human language, which for me constitutes evidence against Chomsky's theory. - Thank you for this commentary. Very complete and persuasive.
Complete thread:
- Chomsky's book & human language -
dhw,
2016-04-02, 13:43
![[*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png "Open whole thread")
- Chomsky's book & human language -
David Turell,
2016-04-02, 16:33
- Chomsky's book & human language -
dhw,
2016-04-03, 13:51
- Chomsky's book & human language -
David Turell,
2016-04-03, 15:40
- How children may pick up a language -
David Turell,
2016-05-07, 22:39
- How children may pick up a language -
dhw,
2016-05-09, 13:05
- How children may pick up a language - David Turell, 2016-05-09, 15:28
- How children pick up a language: another study -
David Turell,
2016-06-07, 16:27
- How children pick up a language: not instinct -
David Turell,
2016-06-11, 19:13
- How children pick up a language: not instinct -
dhw,
2016-06-12, 12:42
- How children pick up a language: not instinct - David Turell, 2016-06-12, 21:20
- How children pick up a language: defending Chomsky -
David Turell,
2016-07-24, 23:59
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky -
David Turell,
2016-08-28, 00:30
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky -
dhw,
2016-08-28, 16:21
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-07, 22:43
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-08, 12:30
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-08, 21:15
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-09, 13:03
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-09, 15:31
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-10, 12:59
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-10, 16:35
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-11, 13:09
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-11, 15:10
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-12, 12:15
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-12, 18:06
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-13, 11:46
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-14, 02:07
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-14, 12:34
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-14, 16:16
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-15, 12:44
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-15, 19:13
- How children pick up a language: Review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-12, 18:12
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-21, 21:57
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-23, 08:32
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-23, 20:36
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-24, 13:14
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-24, 15:50
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-25, 12:31
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-25, 15:24
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-26, 12:26
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-26, 15:15
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-27, 10:28
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-27, 19:20
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-28, 12:46
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-28, 14:41
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-29, 13:14
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-30, 00:37
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-30, 12:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-30, 14:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-31, 11:47
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-31, 17:03
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-01, 14:28
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-01, 17:53
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-02, 13:09
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-02, 19:57
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-03, 11:30
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-03, 18:01
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-04, 13:04
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-04, 17:31
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-05, 12:21
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-05, 14:11
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-06, 13:19
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-06, 14:57
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-07, 13:44
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-07, 17:26
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-08, 12:07
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-08, 14:41
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-09, 13:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-09, 14:42
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-10, 13:01
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-10, 21:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-11, 12:00
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-11, 15:30
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-12, 12:46
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-12, 15:40
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-13, 13:12
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-13, 19:40
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-14, 12:07
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-14, 17:44
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-15, 13:53
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-15, 20:12
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-16, 12:19
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-16, 20:04
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-17, 12:33
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-17, 19:51
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-18, 12:36
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-18, 14:54
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-19, 12:17
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-19, 19:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-20, 12:08
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-20, 15:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-21, 12:35
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-21, 15:35
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-22, 12:08
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-22, 14:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-23, 12:20
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-23, 14:13
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-24, 13:21
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe - David Turell, 2016-11-24, 15:09
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-24, 13:21
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-23, 14:13
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-23, 12:20
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-22, 14:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-22, 12:08
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-21, 15:35
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-21, 12:35
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-20, 15:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-20, 12:08
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-19, 19:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-19, 12:17
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-18, 14:54
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-18, 12:36
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-17, 19:51
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-17, 12:33
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-16, 20:04
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-16, 12:19
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-15, 20:12
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-15, 13:53
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-14, 17:44
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-14, 12:07
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-13, 19:40
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-13, 13:12
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-12, 18:27
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-11-30, 22:42
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-01, 13:22
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-01, 19:21
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-02, 10:42
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-03, 00:48
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-03, 13:41
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-03, 14:40
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-04, 12:16
- How children pick up a language: Everett's view -
David Turell,
2017-01-10, 14:49
- How children pick up a language: Everett's view - dhw, 2017-01-11, 12:24
- How children pick up a language: Everett's view -
David Turell,
2017-01-10, 14:49
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-04, 12:16
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-03, 14:40
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-03, 13:41
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-03, 00:48
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-02, 10:42
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-12-01, 19:21
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-03-05, 00:09
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-03-05, 13:43
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-03-05, 18:18
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
Balance_Maintained,
2017-03-05, 21:33
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-03-06, 00:45
- How children pick up a language: new comment - Balance_Maintained, 2017-03-06, 01:23
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-03-06, 00:45
- How children pick up a language: new comment - dhw, 2017-03-06, 12:53
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
Balance_Maintained,
2017-03-05, 21:33
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-03-05, 18:18
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-07-17, 19:47
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-08-01, 22:41
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-08-02, 14:17
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-08-02, 19:50
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-08-03, 10:57
- How children pick up a language: new comment - David Turell, 2017-08-03, 14:59
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-08-03, 10:57
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-08-02, 19:50
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-08-02, 14:17
- How children pick up a language: new study re words - David Turell, 2019-01-30, 23:03
- How children pick up a language: eight month old baby study -
David Turell,
2020-03-13, 14:55
- How children pick up a language: both sides used early -
David Turell,
2020-09-08, 00:51
- How children pick up a language: Danish is difficult -
David Turell,
2021-06-28, 17:43
- How children pick up a language: Chomsky supported -
David Turell,
2021-08-28, 15:05
- How children pick up a language: fetal speech -
David Turell,
2024-07-25, 19:16
- How children pick up a language: latest review - David Turell, 2024-08-22, 19:01
- How children pick up a language: fetal speech -
David Turell,
2024-07-25, 19:16
- How children pick up a language: Chomsky supported -
David Turell,
2021-08-28, 15:05
- How children pick up a language: Danish is difficult -
David Turell,
2021-06-28, 17:43
- How children pick up a language: both sides used early -
David Turell,
2020-09-08, 00:51
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
David Turell,
2017-08-01, 22:41
- How children pick up a language: new comment -
dhw,
2017-03-05, 13:43
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
dhw,
2016-12-01, 13:22
- How children pick up a language: Pinker's view -
David Turell,
2016-11-30, 22:42
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-12, 15:40
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-12, 12:46
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-11, 15:30
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-11, 12:00
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-10, 21:16
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-10, 13:01
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-09, 14:42
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-09, 13:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-08, 14:41
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-08, 12:07
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-07, 17:26
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-07, 13:44
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-06, 14:57
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-06, 13:19
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-05, 14:11
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-05, 12:21
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-04, 17:31
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-04, 13:04
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-03, 18:01
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-03, 11:30
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-02, 19:57
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-02, 13:09
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-11-01, 17:53
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-11-01, 14:28
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-31, 17:03
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-31, 11:47
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-30, 14:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-30, 12:10
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-30, 00:37
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-29, 13:14
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-28, 14:41
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-28, 12:46
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-27, 19:20
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-27, 10:28
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-26, 15:15
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-26, 12:26
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-25, 15:24
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-25, 12:31
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-24, 15:50
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-24, 13:14
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-23, 20:36
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
dhw,
2016-10-23, 08:32
- How children pick up a language: new review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-21, 21:57
- How children pick up a language: Review of Wolfe -
David Turell,
2016-10-12, 18:12
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-15, 19:13
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-15, 12:44
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-14, 16:16
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-14, 12:34
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-14, 02:07
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-13, 11:46
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-12, 18:06
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-12, 12:15
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-11, 15:10
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-11, 13:09
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-10, 16:35
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-10, 12:59
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-09, 15:31
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-09, 13:03
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-08, 21:15
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
dhw,
2016-09-08, 12:30
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky 2 -
David Turell,
2016-09-07, 22:43
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky -
dhw,
2016-08-28, 16:21
- How children pick up a language: denying Chomsky -
David Turell,
2016-08-28, 00:30
- How children pick up a language: not instinct -
dhw,
2016-06-12, 12:42
- How children pick up a language: not instinct -
David Turell,
2016-06-11, 19:13
- How children may pick up a language -
dhw,
2016-05-09, 13:05
- How children may pick up a language -
David Turell,
2016-05-07, 22:39
- Chomsky's book & human language -
David Turell,
2016-04-03, 15:40
- Chomsky's book & human language -
dhw,
2016-04-03, 13:51
- Chomsky's book & human language -
David Turell,
2016-04-02, 16:33