Balance of nature: bees need meat (Introduction)

by David Turell , Saturday, August 24, 2019, 16:06 (1918 days ago) @ dhw

DAVID: Once again this study shows how the the econiche systems of the balance of nature are very complex and intricate and show why evolution had to develop such a huge diverse bush of life.

dhw: Of course all the econiches are complex and intricate and delicately balanced, and for billions of years they have appeared and disappeared, and they are still doing so even in our own day. According to you, it is not “evolution” that had to develop anything. According to you, your God designed every single econiche extant and extinct, and every one in the whole history of this huge diverse bush had the sole purpose of getting life forms to eat or be eaten by one another in order to “cover” the 3.X billion years your God had decided to spend before designing the only thing he wanted to design. This is why I complain that in our discussions you never COMBINE the different part of your theory, and it is the COMBINATION that defies all logic.

Of course it defies all of your logic. You are an agnostic who does not accept God, but is not sure about whether He might exist or what He does or is capable of doing. We are on different sides of the chasm. Agnosticism is not illogical, but a state of a mind's thoughts and decisions, in a framework of its own decisions.