Neanderthal research (Introduction)

by Balance_Maintained , U.S.A., Saturday, July 30, 2011, 07:12 (4865 days ago) @ xeno6696

Geological evidence would offer SOMETHING to support the idea of technologically advanced civilizations--which is where I know you're going with this--Pompeii, Ashfall NE, other sites in China, India, etc. Chichen Itza and Coba were "swallowed by mother nature" yet the pyramids still stand; the Great Pyramid in Egypt was also once buried. There are several sites for civilization dating back to 5100 in Meso America, I've heard some estimates as far back as 10k years. But no evidence of any kind of civilization on par with our own--they certainly never cracked the atom, or harnessed oil. 
> 
> If an ancient, pre stone-age civilization was that advanced, there would be solid evidence for it. 
> -
I don't necessarily disagree with you. I see some quite large gaping holes in your logic, though. -A) You are assuming that any advanced pre-stoneage civilization would 'evolve' along the same lines that we did. i.e. They would use the same types of materials etc etc etc. While this is possibly true, it is also possibly false. Much of the materials we used today are based on petroleum, if a hypothetical civilization did exist, there are other sources of energy they could have used that would not have produced the same type of material byproducts. -B) You are using the non-existence of evidence as evidence of non-existence. -C) You are assuming that we have looked in the right places already, and that we have dug deep enough in those places to find it.-D) You are asumming that natural geological events have not eradicated the evidence(glacial migrations, volcanos, earthquakes, tectonic subduction, yada yada yada).--Anyway, I wasn't particularly leading anywhere with my comments. To me it was more of a, "Well, tomorrow they will be saying something different" moment. My main beef with topics like this is NOT that they change the theories and hypotheses, but that they teach the theories and hypotheses as facts. Bad juju in my opinion.