New model of Peer Review (The limitations of science)

by David Turell , Tuesday, August 17, 2010, 14:48 (5792 days ago) @ xeno6696

This is EXACTLY what science needs... a centralized server (wikipedia) that allows debate and evolving views. > > > > I agree with you but arXiv is delivered for credentialed folks and is a centralized resource. I used it in my book. A series of arXiv's with discussion forum areas for each aspect of science would do the same thing. One Wikipedia for prepublication papers would be ponderous. > > I'm confused... wasn't part of your issue with the current system that "credentialed" people are blocking access via PR?-arXiv is open to anyone with the proper credentials in physical science to present pre-publication work. To my knowledge 'open' means open to submit. No PR. I guess my comment above was confusing.