AgnosticWeb.com - Who\'s Who Here?

Who\'s Who Here? (reply)

George Jelliss — Fri, 25 Jan 2008 11:46:34 +0000

The people who promote Intelligent Design are not always as honest and upfront about their motives as they could be, and I have a nasty suspicious nature. - However in this case it seems the author is just being a little over-modest, and perhaps nervous about coming forward into an unfamiliar arena of controversy. - xxxxxxxxxx - Item relating to DHW Removed by Web Co-ordination Team - The request by the guide's author was that comment / criticism should directed at the guide and not at the author. I'm sure in due course all will be revealed. In the meantime, nice bit of investigation - full marks for super sleuthing. If I am informed that this situation has changed I will re-instate George's comment. - Neil - xxxxxxxxxx - It is of course perfectly possible to judge the value of a writer's views purely from what they write, but it's nice to have some background colour. - I delayed posting this in the expectation that the author would reply himself, but he hasn't chosen to do so.

Who\'s Who Here? (reply)

whitecraw — Fri, 25 Jan 2008 00:34:46 +0000

Why? Of what relevance is the identity of the writer to the validity of the arguments s/he writes?

Who\'s Who Here? (reply)

meclayto — Fri, 18 Jan 2008 20:08:09 +0000

This is a valid request. I too would like to know something of the background this site's creator. - clayto

Who\'s Who Here?

George Jelliss — Wed, 16 Jan 2008 14:29:20 +0000

It would be advisable for D. H. Wilson to identify himself (or herself?) a little more with some biographical background, since there are a lot of D. Wilson's about! We know from the H that he is not David Sloan Wilson who argues with Richard Dawkins about group selection. But he might be Douglas Wilson (a US theologian) author of "Letter from a Christian Citizen" in response to Sam Harris. Or he might be David Harlan Wilson, a science fiction writer. Or ...?