More "miscellany" (General)

by dhw, Sunday, April 10, 2022, 13:31 (718 days ago) @ David Turell

ID

DAVID: Exactly. I accept God knows exactly what he is doing, making sense to Himself, while you get bent all out of shape in trying to analyze Him when you find what He does is is nonsense to you.

dhw: As usual you conflate your illogical theory with objective fact. You believe he created every life form, natural wonder etc. individually as preparation for and part of “THE GOAL OF EVOLVING [= DESIGNING] HUMANS” AND OUR FOOD.” This is not fact. This is your theory. And when I point out that the vast majority of extinct life forms did not lead to humans and our food, you say only God can explain it all. You know perfectly well that I am not “analyzing” him, but am analyzing your senseless theory about what he did and why. Please stop dodging.

DAVID: I've fully explained how all the branches are ecosystem food. They are required for our huge population, which God certainly anticipated. as for humans we know the branches that led to us.

How can all the extinct branches and ecosystems be required for our huge population? When did you last eat trilobite trifle or baked brontosaurus bottom? You have said yourself that they were for the past and not the present. According to you, we were God’s one and only purpose right from the start, but the hominins and homos that led to us were not there from the start, and nor were countless other life forms that did not lead to us. All food required for our huge population?

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/fruit-flies-evolve-in-time-with-the-seasons-...

DAVID: As usual your weird view of design has God relinquishing control of directionality to His goal of humans. (dhw’s bold)

dhw: And this leads you straight to your senseless theory above, since most of his designs did NOT lead to humans and their food.

DAVID: And don't you see the food necessity?! Most of His designs lead to food! I wish you could open your mind to the requirements for initiating new design with directionality, which I what I see God doing.

The history of life does not reveal to us that every single life form and food was specially designed and directed to “His goal of humans” plus our food. You keep editing out the blatant illogicalities of your theory. Please don’t. Please just stick to your oft repeated admission that you can’t explain it.

Trilobites

Dealt with in your theory Part One.


Complete thread:

 RSS Feed of thread

powered by my little forum