Confusing cosmology (Introduction)

by David Turell @, Sunday, January 05, 2014, 20:46 (3975 days ago)

Looking for wimps:-http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=dark-matters-elusiveness-means-search-may-soon-become-more-challenging&WT.mc_id=SA_DD_20140103

Confusing cosmology; flat?

by David Turell @, Friday, January 31, 2014, 15:11 (3949 days ago) @ David Turell

An excellent presentation of the 'flatness' problem, which is now the accepted form of the universe's geometry:
http://www.uncommondescent.com/intelligent-design/why-astronomers-say-we-live-in-a-remarkably-flat-universe-and-what-that-really-means/

Confusing cosmology; white dwarf doesn't fit theory

by David Turell @, Saturday, April 29, 2017, 23:25 (2765 days ago) @ David Turell

It is acting like a slowly revolving pulsar. No one knows why:

https://cosmosmagazine.com/space/an-old-star-learns-new-tricks

"We have always dismissed these aged fellows as defunct relics of a sun-sized star. Now one has surprised us. Instead of going off gently into that good night, it is zapping the universe with a spinning beam of radiation. For astrophysicists like me, this is like hearing a retired centenarian has entered the world heavyweight boxing championships and is punching with the best of them.

***

"The white dwarf, AR Scorpii, and a larger companion star (a red dwarf) are located 380 light years away. Separated from each other by just three times the distance between the Earth and Moon, they orbit each other every four hours.

"Till now, if you had have asked me to describe the typical life story of a white dwarf, my explanation would have gone something like this.

"Fast-forward the next five billion years to see the Sun age before your very eyes. Its surface reddens and bloats as fusion reactions relocate to the outer layers; its shapely edges blur as its atmosphere drifts off into space. Now known as a red giant, it engulfs Mercury and Venus, almost certainly Earth and possibly Mars.

"At the end of those five billion years, the Sun’s nuclear fusion furnace has used up its fuel. Absent the outward pressure, it collapses under its own gravity.

"The result is an Earth-sized object – about one millionth its original size. After 10 billion years of fusion, the Sun is gone, the remaining carbon atoms crushed till they form a near-perfect lattice akin to a diamond. Each teaspoon’s worth of material equals a ton in mass.

"It is now a white dwarf. Though the star’s surface continues to glow white hot at more than 100,000 Kelvin, it is effectively dead, slowly fading to leave a black dwarf, with no more role to play in the evolution of the galaxy.

"AR Scorpii, however, is different. Rather than fading away, it has been acting more like a lighthouse, spinning on its axis every two minutes and emitting a tightly focused beam of radiation along its magnetic poles. Like a giant dynamo, the beam is powered by a magnetic field a 100 million times that of Earth’s.

"In emitting its regular rotating beam, AR Scorpii is behaving like a pulsar, albeit a slow one. These cosmic beacons usually spin with a period of seconds rather than minutes and were previously thought to be powered only by neutron stars, the end state of a star with a mass at least three times that of the Sun. Even more dense than a white dwarf, a teaspoonful of neutron star weighs a billion tonnes.

***

"Just how AR Scorpii acquired the superpowers of a neutron star is a mystery that has astrophysicists bemused. White dwarves are not supposed to be able to do this! Only neutron stars were thought to be able to power the pulsars seen in their thousands across the galaxy. Now we know different.

"This isn’t the first time researchers have suggested a white dwarf might not just be a silent senior citizen. In 2008, Japanese astrophysicist Yukikatsu Terada and colleagues published an article in the Publications of the Astronomical Society of Japan that showed the rapidly rotating white dwarf AE Aquarii was pulsating X-rays.

" Just how AR Scorpii acquired the superpowers of a neutron star is a mystery to astrophysicists. White dwarves are not supposed to be able to do this! Only neutron stars were thought to be able to power pulsars. Now we know different.

"To change a textbook, it is great to have more than one exception to the rule. Which white dwarf ultimately lays claim to the crown of “first” pulsar heavyweight is less important than the fact that something as extraordinary as an Earth-sized diamond crystal can hold even more surprises for astronomers."

Comment: The universe is weird. We keep observing to learn how it works, as it keeps surprising. The underlying question is why is it built with all these strange parts. Recognizing that it is fine tuned for life doesn't answer the underlying issue.

Confusing cosmology; our sun is less magnetic than others

by David Turell @, Thursday, April 30, 2020, 20:58 (1668 days ago) @ David Turell
edited by David Turell, Thursday, April 30, 2020, 21:03

A new finding:

https://www.sciencenews.org/article/sun-less-magnetically-active-than-similar-stars

"A census of stars similar to the sun shows that our own star is less magnetically active than others of its kind, astrophysicists report in the May 1 Science. The result could support the idea that the sun is in a “midlife crisis,” transitioning into a quieter phase of life. Or, alternatively, it could mean that the sun has capacity for much more magnetic oomph than it’s shown in the past.

***

"A star’s magnetism can drive dramatic outbursts like flares and coronal mass ejections, which can cause chaos on orbiting planets (SN: 3/5/18). When these large ejections from the sun hit Earth, they can knock out satellites, shut down power grids and trigger beautiful auroras. Understanding the sun’s magnetic field is thought to be the key to predicting such outbursts.

***

"Surprisingly, although the stars with no detectable rotation periods looked as magnetically calm as the sun, the stars with sunlike rotations were up to five times as active.
Either something is different about those stars, Reinhold says, or the sun may go through periods of greater variability in its brightness — and thus, magnetic activity — that scientists just haven’t seen. Perhaps “the sun did not reveal its full range of activity over the last 9,000 years,” he says. “The sun is 4.5 billion years old; 9,000 years is nothing.”

***

"The new result “could be the best evidence yet that the sun is in the midst of a magnetic midlife crisis,” Metcalfe says. The hyperactive stars in Reinhold’s sample appear to be slightly younger than the sun, and so may not have gone through their magnetic transition yet. The sun and the other calmer stars could already be on the other side."

Comment: this fits my theory that God controls all levels of evolution, and since a quieter sun is safer for human civilization, He arranged for this circumstance. Here is an article that worries about it tooting up:

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2242105-the-sun-is-too-quiet-which-may-mean-danger...

"Regardless, the fact that there are sun-like stars with much higher variability suggests it is possible that the sun could be in a temporarily calm phase now and its activity may ramp up in the future, says Reinhold. He says that while we can’t predict exactly when this could happen, it would lead to brighter auroras and potentially dangerous solar eruptions that could damage our electrical grids."

Comment: Since we cannot predict, we'll wait and see.

Confusing cosmology; our sun is less magnetic than others

by dhw, Friday, May 01, 2020, 12:03 (1667 days ago) @ David Turell

QUOTE: "Regardless, the fact that there are sun-like stars with much higher variability suggests it is possible that the sun could be in a temporarily calm phase now and its activity may ramp up in the future, says Reinhold. He says that while we can’t predict exactly when this could happen, it would lead to brighter auroras and potentially dangerous solar eruptions that could damage our electrical grids."

DAVID: Since we cannot predict, we'll wait and see.

Damage to our electrical grids is the least of our worries! Look what an invisible virus can do to us! A major change to the sun could destroy the whole planet. We’d better not make your hands-on God too angry!

Confusing cosmology; our sun is less magnetic than others

by David Turell @, Friday, May 01, 2020, 21:47 (1667 days ago) @ dhw

QUOTE: "Regardless, the fact that there are sun-like stars with much higher variability suggests it is possible that the sun could be in a temporarily calm phase now and its activity may ramp up in the future, says Reinhold. He says that while we can’t predict exactly when this could happen, it would lead to brighter auroras and potentially dangerous solar eruptions that could damage our electrical grids."

DAVID: Since we cannot predict, we'll wait and see.

dhw: Damage to our electrical grids is the least of our worries! Look what an invisible virus can do to us! A major change to the sun could destroy the whole planet. We’d better not make your hands-on God too angry!

Did it occur to you that our calm sun is God's handiwork, protecting us?

Confusing cosmology; what we do not know

by David Turell @, Friday, March 26, 2021, 14:17 (1338 days ago) @ David Turell

There are huge gaps in our knowledge about the universe:

https://aeon.co/essays/we-are-at-a-crossroads-in-the-search-for-a-new-physics?utm_sourc...

"While physicists have been busily verifying ideas devised in the past century, we’ve made almost no progress in figuring out where to go in this one. In fact, we’re at a complete loss at how to explain some of the most fundamental but baffling observations of how our Universe behaves. There is a tremendous, even cosmic, chasm between the physics we know and love, and some of the phenomena that we observe, but simply can’t make head nor tail of. We have no idea how to bridge this chasm – yet we are proceeding, at pace, to construct ever more expensive experiments and observatories in the hope that we will.

***

"Dubbed the theory of inflation – because the Universe inflated uncontrollably during that period – it’s very elegant and mathematically simple, but also highly speculative. The reality is that we have no idea what actually happened at the beginning of the Universe; if it was inflation, what was driving it; how it came about; and how it ended.

"If what happened at the beginning of the Universe is a mystery, what’s happening now is no less puzzling. We’ve come to realise that most of the matter in the Universe, the stuff that gravitates around galaxies, for example, is dark. In other words, it doesn’t emit or reflect light like the particles from the Standard Model, or the atoms and molecules that we’re familiar with from the lab. This dark matter outnumbers ordinary matter by a factor of six to one, and underpins any explanation of why the Universe looks the way it does on the largest scales. We know almost nothing about what it actually is, apart from the fact that it coalesces under the pull of gravity. Whether it’s one type of particle or an amalgam of different types of particles, whether it could be something more complex and substantial, like a sea of black holes, or some kind of quantum field, the explanation is completely up for grabs. And that’s been the situation since the idea of dark matter first took off more than 50 years ago.

"Dark matter is only a small part of a much wider sea of dark stuff that permeates the Universe. Since the mid-1980s, we’ve had an inkling that the Universe isn’t expanding as we might expect. And, in recent years, we’ve found incontrovertible evidence that the Universe’s expansion is in fact speeding up – driven, it seems, by some form of energy that doesn’t clump under the pull of gravity like ‘ordinary’ energy. Rather, it’s repulsive, pushing space and time apart, and doesn’t emit or interact with light. One possibility is that the dark energy is simply a constant, undiluted by the expansion of the Universe. This cosmological constant was first invented by Einstein when he constructed his general theory of relativity, but was put aside for almost a century as superfluous (and, in his mind, pointless). While it’s favoured by many, it has such bizarre properties, that it jars with the rest of physics. And so, as with the dark matter, we really have no idea what this dark energy is.

"These three puzzles – how the Universe began, what dark matter is, and what dark energy consists of – make a compelling science case for future particle accelerators, observatories and satellite missions.

***

"And so we come back to our seemingly unbridgeable, cosmic chasm – between tried and tested physics, and the exotic effects we see playing themselves out on cosmic scales. On the one hand, we have a set of laws of physics, a mathematical model that works perfectly well and that we’ve confirmed with exquisite prediction. Yet we’re at a loss about how to address the true nature of what dark matter, dark energy and inflation really are.

***

"I’ve spent most of my adult life staring at the cosmic chasm – the abyss between what we know and what we don’t. And while our knowledge of the Universe has improved dramatically in that time, our ignorance has become only more focused. We’re no closer to answering the big questions about dark matter, dark energy and the origins of the Universe than when I started out. This isn’t for lack of trying, and a titanic effort is now underway to try and figure out all these mysterious aspects of the Universe. But there’s no guarantee we’ll succeed, and we might end up never really grasping how the Universe works. That’s why we need to be creative and to explore. As Einstein once said: ‘Let the people know that a new type of thinking is essential if mankind is to survive and move toward higher levels.’ While bridging the cosmic chasm might not be a matter of survival, undoubtedly it’s one of the most pressing challenges of modern science."

Comment: The 50+ year old string theory and wild ideas about a multiverse are ample evidence of the author's conundrum. All questions created by the human brain that has no natural reason for being here.

RSS Feed of thread
powered by my little forum